"There are several views in the commission on Shoaib's injury," chairman of the medical commission Dr M A Wajid told BBC Radio Hindi service shortly after the speedster appeared before the panel.
Dr Wajid said he would submit the panel's report, including its final decision on Shoaib, to the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) by next Friday.
Shoaib, who also spoke to BBC Radio, said he had a "medically documented rib injury" and that he had told the team management about it as well as his inability to bowl in the Test which India went on to win by an innings.
The controversial bowler claimed that his report presented to the committee confirmed that he "had a slight injury on the 11th rib, which was evident in the scan".
He said the injury "has since healed, partially", as he has been "resting for the past fortnight".
When asked whether the medical commission was satisfied with his version and the report, the 'Rawalpindi Express' said: "I have made my statement to the commission, and it is for them to decide."